Made In Investigation: What’s the Best Cookware Material?

Cookware can be confusing. That's why we're here to help you determine the best cookware material for you.

Stainless steel. Carbon steel. Non stick. While shopping for pots and pans, you've probably seen all of these cookware options. But what are the strengths of each? How are you supposed to decide between them? If you're trying to figure out what the best cookware material for you is, use our handy guide that contains cookware material similarities and differences.

While general properties and characteristics of each material are typically similar across brands, some specific qualities (such as durability and heat tolerance) do vary by brand. So it's easy to follow along, all cookware material information listed in this article refers specifically to Made In's version of that cookware material.

Stainless Steel Cookware

  • Heat conductivity: Stainless steel cookware conducts heat like a champ. With a quality 5-ply stainless steel pot, you'll be surprised at how quickly water boils when compared to anodized aluminum and aluminum cookware.
  • Heat retention: Stainless steel cookware retains heat incredibly well. Much like cast iron cookware, stainless steel pans can continue cooking your food after the burner has been turned off because of how well they hold the heat applied to them. Unlike cast iron pans, they're much lighter.
  • Heat tolerance: A quality stainless steel pan can tolerate high heats of up to 800F.
  • Durability: With proper care, stainless steel will stay looking and performing as if it were brand new forever. Stainless steel is nonreactive, meaning acidic foods will have no effect on it. In order to avoid nicks and dents, we don't recommend using metal utensils in stainless steel pots and pans.
  • Ease of care: If you use a quality stainless steel cleaner like Made In's Make It Like New Cleaner, cleaning stainless steel is a breeze. You can go from a caked on mess to a sparkling clean finish in under one minute.
  • Stick resistance: When properly preheated, stainless steel cookware sticks much less than it does otherwise. Unlike carbon steel and non stick cookware, though, stainless steel cookware doesn't boast stick resistant properties.
  • Additional notes: Many people use stainless steel saute pans, saucepans, and stock pots as replacements for Dutch ovens. Made In stainless steel products are all uncoated and feature a brushed finish.
  • You should use this cookware material if: You're after an all around workhorse pot or pan that takes heat incredibly well, looks and performs like new for a lifetime, and is nonreactive.

stainless steel cookware

Carbon Steel Cookware

  • Heat conductivity: Carbon steel cookware is an incredible conductor of heat. It can get very hot, very fast.
  • Heat retention: As far as retaining heat after being removed from the heating element goes, carbon steel isn't as good as stainless. However, carbon steel cookware is amazing at maintaining a consistent heat level while heat is being applied to it. This gives carbon steel unparalleled heat control.
  • Heat tolerance: A quality carbon steel pan can tolerate heats of up to 1200F. It's a cookware material that can handle an incredibly high heat!
  • Durability: If properly cared for, carbon steel cookware lasts forever and only gets better with age as it seasons. Any scratches in carbon steel pans fill in and season over time, so metal utensils are fine to use with them.
  • Ease of care: Carbon steel cookware is a little trickier to care for than stainless steel and non stick cookware. Carbon steel is reactive, which means cooking acidic foods such as tomatoes in a carbon steel pan isn't recommended because it can strip away your pan's seasoning. Carbon steel cookware is also not dishwasher safe, as it can rust in moist environments.
  • Stick resistance: Carbon steel acquires non stick properties through seasoning and use.
  • Additional notes: Many people replace cast iron cookware with carbon steel because it's so much lighter and conducts heat so much faster. Unlike stainless steel, carbon steel may change color with use (this is totally normal). All Made In carbon steel pans come unseasoned and without any sort of coating. Carbon steel's composition is similar to that of cast iron but with, ironically, a lower carbon content (99% iron, 1% carbon) — this means those who have been advised to avoid cast iron for medical reasons should also avoid carbon steel.
  • You should use this cookware material if: you want to cook at a very high heat and have total control over what you cook while having less cleanup to do afterwards.
carbon steel cookware

Non Stick Cookware

  • Heat conductivity and retention: This depends on the cookware material beneath the non stick layer. Beneath the coating of Made In non stick frying pans is 5-ply stainless steel, meaning superior heat conductivity and retention.
  • Heat tolerance: Non sticks should never be used above medium heat to protect the coating from overheating. Made In non stick pans are oven safe up to 500F.
  • Durability: Made In non sticks are made of nonreactive all American PTFE and are coated multiple times to ensure durability. Non sticks with lower quality coating processes will be much less durable. Make sure you don't place other pans or metal utensils in your non stick cookware to avoid damaging the coating.
  • Ease of care: Non stick pans are as easy to care for as they come. A quick, gentle scrub will have your non stick pan looking good as new. Follow some simple non stick care guidelines and you're good to go.
  • Stick resistance:  It's in the name: non stick!
  • Additional notes: Many people like to use non stick to cut down on their oil intake. However, to prevent the coating from overheating, never preheat your non stick without at least some oil or food inside.
  • You should use this cookware material if: you want something that is easy to clean, can cook delicate foods with ease, and is nonreactive.

non stick cookware

    Made up your mind on what the best type of cookware material suits you? Shop Made In's award-winning lines of stainless steel cookware, carbon steel cookware, and non stick cookware now!

    Related Articles

    Made In & Nancy Silverton: Behind the Collection
    Made In & Nancy Silverton: Behind the Collection
    by George Steckel It's fair to say that Made In’s partnership with Nancy Silverton has been yea...
    Read Now
    My Perfect Food Day: Gabe Erales
    My Perfect Food Day: Gabe Erales
    by Leah Bhabha For chefs, meals take myriad forms, from a spoonful of a dish in development to a ...
    Read Now
    How Foster Has Adapted During a Pandemic
    How Foster Has Adapted During a Pandemic
    by George Steckel For Foster, South by Southwest (SXSW) is the most important time of the year. ...
    Read Now

    1 comment

    • Rory Roberts

      Good synopsis, but can you also comment on which will work on induction cooktops? Thanks

    Leave a comment

    Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

    Select Add-On Items

    Add to cart

    How Made In Sizing Works

    sizing chart
    sizing chart

    Sizing Guide